Personal responsibility is
just that - personal. If you do something stupid
and you get injured or hurt, then it is your own fault. It's
not McDonald's fault if you get fat, it's not Phillip Morris' fault if
you smoke and get lung cancer; it's your fault. One
of the biggest problems facing America is that many people want to find
someone to blame for everything that happens to them. Well
sometimes it's your own fault, sometimes it's just bad luck and
sometimes it is truly someone else's fault. But
let's get away from this victimhood mentality and back to standing on
our own two feet and taking responsibility for our own actions.
After being out of the
country for two
weeks, one of the first news reports I saw on early morning television
in Miami concerned an accident at a carnival. From
the
report, it appears that a teenage girl got injured when she went on the
tea cup ride at a carnival, got too dizzy and fell and hit her head.
So naturally, at least in this country, they were
going to sue.
Let me get this straight,
isn't the purpose of the tea cup ride to go in circles as fast as you
can to get dizzy? Don't you actually turn a wheel
in the middle to make it spin even faster? Isn't
that why people, like me who can't deal with being dizzy, don't go on
that type of ride? Does the ride operator have to
conduct pre-ride tests to determine if the person going on the ride
can't deal with dizzy? Even then, they would
probably be sued by people who felt they were unjustly kept off the
ride.
We engaged in some fairly
risky behavior in Costa Rica. We took a zip line
tour through the jungle trees. We drove, including
the underage members of our families, ATV's across the beach and
through the jungle at high rates of speed. We went
snorkeling in the open ocean. We took numerous
small boats across the ocean and down crocodile filled rivers.
Never
once did we sign a liability waiver or a notice that we were engaging
in hazardous activities that could result in injury or death.
Could we have gotten hurt? Yes,
and there were some minor injuries from the ATV excursions, but it was
up to us as adults to determine if we wanted to engage in the
activities and take the risks associated with them.
The explosion of liability
lawsuits and
the desire of people to want to sue for just about any perceived injury
or injustice are completely out of control in this country. How many
millions of decisions are made every day based on the fact that, "We
better do this to cover ourselves in case we are sued"? Not because it
is necessary, but just as insurance from getting sued.
How often have you heard
even children say something about suing someone for some perceived
wrong. It has become a national mindset and it is
not good for the country.
The Tort Tax is a major
drain on this country. It
has been estimated recently by authors McQuillan and Apramyan that our
current legal system and the desire of everyone to sue is costing this
country as much as $865 billion per year, or to put it another way,
$9,827 per year for a family of four. If people
were
actually paying this amount directly out of their pockets there would
be revolt in the streets, but instead, this is a hidden levy on all
Americans and costs each of us every day.
Here's where the
costs come from and how we get hit with those costs every day.
First, there are
the costs of litigation which are added to the cost of every product we
buy every day. No
matter what anyone makes these days there is the very real chance that
someone is going to sue the maker of that product because they were
"hurt" using it. Doesn't matter if they did
something entirely stupid, surely the manufacturer is still somewhat to
blame. Next
time you are in a hardware store look at all the warnings on ladders to
see all the ways the manufacturer has to warn the user to try and
prevent themselves from getting sued and it still doesn't prevent that
from happening. In our office building there was an
entire law firm that did nothing but represent ladder makers against
lawsuits and they had to move because they needed more room for more
lawyers.
Second, medical
liability is a major factor in increasing health care costs.
The
fear of being sued has prompted many doctors to routinely engage in
defensive and expensive medical practices by ordering extra tests and
sending people to specialists just to cover themselves in case some one
decides to sue. It has also caused a severe
shortage in
several medical specialties such as obstetrics as doctors just get
tired of being sued for things that are completely out of their control.
In the current health care
debate the
question needs to be asked, "How many more people would have health
insurance coverage if the cost of medical insurance was much lower?"
Also,
an interesting side note is that in the medical systems that Michael
Moore held out to be excellent examples of universal care around the
world there is almost no recourse for medical malpractice, regardless
of how incompetent the doctors might be.
Third, innovation
is also stifled by the cost of litigation in this company.
It
doesn't matter how well a product works or what benefit it has if there
is the slightest chance that someone can figure out a way to improperly
use it and hurt themselves. Also, as companies have
to
pay ever increasing costs for their product liability insurance they
have even less to spend on developing new products which, in turn,
causes less economic growth.
The bottom line of all this
is that, as
President, one of the main aspects of American life that I would
attempt to reform would be that of legal liability. I'm
not for letting someone off the hook if they truly develop a faulty
product and put it in the marketplace or if they are truly responsible
for injuring someone else, but at the same time we need to be a nation
of adults and take responsibility for our own actions.
How would I work to reform
legal
liability since most liability questions are state issues and not the
responsibility of the Federal government?
- I would do so by
appointing Federal judges who believe that people should be responsible
for their own actions.
- I would appoint Federal
judges who
believe that life itself is risky and that sometimes bad things just
happen and no one is at fault.
- I would appoint Federal
judges who
believe that it should be easier for people who are sued to collect
their defense costs when they beat those that sue them.
- I would appoint Federal
judges who
believe that the practice of medicine is not an exact science and that
unless doctors make blatant errors that maybe they aren't to "blame"
when things don't work out exactly how people believe they should.
I don't know about you, but
this family
of four could sure use an extra $9,000 worth of purchasing power that
we don't have now because of the cost of everyone always wanting to sue
and win the legal lotto.
"Anything is Possible in
America"
Media events that are
coming up include:
On Sunday August 26th, at 4
PM PDT, I will be giving an interview to Brian Wolf on the Free World
Radio Network. The interview may be found by going
to either of the following locations. The first and
the easiest, according to Brian, is to go to www.freeworldradionetwork.net
and look for Brian's show Shakedown Street.
The second way is to go to
the actual URL at: www.blogtalkradio.com/-shakedown-street
(notice the dashes).